• Why do healthcare carriers in some states and all PEO's require dependent level information for all employees enrolled in the firm’s healthcare plan (s)?

 

Healthcare carriers in the small group market in some states by law (NY/NJ/MA/VT) and all PEOs require dependent-level information for employees enrolled in the firm’s health plan(s) primarily for pricing, eligibility verification, and compliance purposes.

​

From a pricing standpoint, medical premiums are calculated based on coverage tier (employee only, employee + spouse, employee + child(ren), family). Accurate dependent data ensures premiums are rated correctly and that the employer is not overpaying or underpaying for coverage.

​

From an eligibility and compliance perspective, carriers are required to confirm that covered dependents meet plan eligibility rules (e.g., legal spouse, domestic partner where applicable, age limits for children). This is also important for claims processing, COBRA administration, and compliance with federal and state regulations.

​

For PEO-sponsored plans specifically, dependent-level detail is also necessary because the PEO pools employees from multiple companies into a single benefits program. Complete enrollment data allows the PEO and carrier to administer coverage accurately across the pooled population.

 

Importantly, this information is used solely for plan administration and compliance, is handled securely, and is not shared beyond what is required to administer benefits.

 

 

• Why do PEO’s need to see a prospective client's most recent healthcare invoice showing all employees enrolled in the healthcare plan (s) and associated monthly premiums being paid, and also want to see either the most recent annual healthcare renewal or the upcoming one (if within 60-90 days)?

 

PEOs request either your most recent annual healthcare renewal or your upcoming renewal (if it’s within the next 60–90 days) because underwriting is fundamentally an exercise in assessing risk, and recent healthcare pricing provides one of the most reliable real-world indicators of that risk.

While underwriters do evaluate a group based on standard factors such as employee demographics, census data, location, industry, and plan design, those inputs only tell part of the story. A recent healthcare invoice or renewal reflects how an insurance carrier has already assessed the group’s risk based on actual claims experience, utilization patterns, and trend assumptions.

​

In other words, your current or upcoming renewal acts as a baseline of assessed risk:

​

• It shows how the market is currently pricing your population

• It reflects recent claims activity without requiring disclosure of individual medical details

• It allows the PEO to align its proposed pricing assumptions with real-world data rather than estimates alone

​​

If a renewal is approaching, using that information helps avoid mismatches between expected and actual costs once the group transitions into a PEO-sponsored plan. For PEOs, this is especially important because they are managing risk not just for one company, but across a pooled population of employers.

​

Importantly, this information is used strictly for underwriting and pricing alignment, not to single out individual employees or diagnose specific conditions.

​

In short, recent healthcare renewals give PEOs a clearer, more accurate picture of group risk, which ultimately leads to more reliable pricing and fewer surprises after implementation.

 

 

• Why do healthcare carriers and PEOs require employers to meet minimum participation thresholds (typically around 50%) for eligible full-time employees enrolled in the health plan(s)?

 

The primary reason for this requirement is to prevent adverse selection. Adverse selection occurs when only employees who expect to use healthcare heavily choose to enroll, while healthier employees opt out. When this happens, the overall claims experience becomes disproportionately high, which drives up costs for everyone and can make the plan financially unviable.

​

By requiring a minimum level of participation, carriers and PEOs ensure that the risk pool includes a balanced mix of healthier and higher utilization employees. This broader participation helps keep premiums more predictable and prevents sudden cost spikes at renewal.

​

Participation rules also create fairness across employers in a pooled or group plan. In PEO arrangements especially, participation standards help protect the integrity of the shared risk pool across all client companies.

​

It’s also worth noting that most plans allow employees with other qualifying coverage (such as coverage through a spouse) to waive enrollment without negatively impacting participation calculations, as long as that coverage is documented.

​

In short, participation requirements exist to keep plans affordable, prevent cost volatility, and protect employers from paying higher premiums due to skewed enrollment.